Every platform change, every algorithm update, every new OTA commission increase — none of it affects your email list. You own it. The names, the stays, the preferences. That list is the most durable, highest-ROI marketing channel most hotels have, and most of them are barely using it.
The average hotel email has an open rate of around 18–22%. Travel and hospitality emails, when done well, can push 30–40%. Compare that to organic social reach of 2–5%, or paid social where you’re paying for every impression. The math is straightforward — and yet most independent hotels send emails only when they want to push a sale.
The Problem With OTA Dependency
Every booking that comes through an OTA is a customer the OTA owns. They have the email address. They have the relationship. They send the pre-arrival communications, the post-stay review request, the loyalty points. Your property fulfilled the stay — but the guest’s next booking behavior was shaped by a platform that collected 15–25% commission on the first one.
Email breaks that dependency. A guest who books direct and opts into your list is a guest you can market to directly for the next stay, the next season, the next promotion — at zero incremental cost.
The lifetime value math: A guest who books twice is worth 2× the revenue minus the OTA commission on the first stay. A guest who books via your email list both times is worth 2× the revenue with no commission removed. The difference compounds over time.
Building the List: Where Emails Actually Come From
The best time to capture an email is when a guest is already engaged with your property. That means multiple touchpoints:
- Booking confirmation — add an explicit opt-in checkbox for offers and property updates
- Check-in process — ask verbally and have a paper or tablet opt-in available
- Wi-Fi landing page — require email for network access (standard practice, low friction)
- Post-stay review request — include a newsletter signup in the follow-up email
- Website — a clear signup offer (early access to seasonal rates, local guides) above the fold
Each touchpoint alone captures a small percentage. Combined systematically, you’re building a list that grows with every occupied room.
What to Actually Send
The biggest mistake is treating the email list as a promotional tool only. “20% off — book now” campaigns erode trust over time and train subscribers to open only when they’re actively looking to book. Instead, build a content rhythm that provides value even when the subscriber isn’t in booking mode.
Email Content Mix That Works
- Seasonal travel guides — what’s happening locally, what to book around
- Insider tips — restaurants, hikes, experiences your front desk actually recommends
- Property updates — renovations, new amenities, staff highlights
- Early access offers — give your list first access to peak availability before it goes public
- Rate promotions — 1 in 4 emails maximum; the other 3 should provide value
Segmentation Changes Everything
A 200-room hotel sending the same email to every subscriber is leaving performance on the table. Basic segmentation produces meaningful lifts in both open rates and conversions.
Start with three segments: guests who’ve stayed once, guests who’ve stayed multiple times, and subscribers who’ve never stayed. Each group has different messaging needs. A first-time guest needs social proof and experience framing. A returning guest needs loyalty acknowledgment and early access. A non-guest subscriber needs a conversion-focused reason to book for the first time.
The Open Rate Is Not the Goal
Open rate tells you how compelling your subject line was. The metric that matters is revenue per email sent — how much direct booking revenue is attributable to the send. Track UTM parameters on all links. Set up conversion tracking in your booking engine. Know which campaigns produced bookings and which produced opens without action.
A 40% open rate with zero clicks is a worse campaign than a 25% open rate with a 5% click-to-booking rate. Optimize toward the outcome, not the vanity metric.
The Film Pack — Lightroom Presets
The analog warmth and tonal shift we get from shooting the Canon Rebel 2000, packaged as a one-click Lightroom preset. 12 presets, desktop and mobile compatible.
Shop Presets — €39 →
